As a general rule of thumb, a surgeon will typically recommend surgery as the treatment of choice, (if you are a good candidate for surgery), simply because that is what surgeons do. If anyone suggests surgery, you owe it to yourself to demand/seek out a 2nd opinion.
My last surgery... one surgeon recommended surgery, said it would fix everything. I went for a second opinion. 2nd surgeon said that he didn't think it would fix my problem. I had to toss a coin, literally, as these were the opinions of the top 2 guys in this field. So, I had the surgery. It fixed everything for 3 months, then it all came back worse than ever. I couldnt' return it, and there was no money back guarrantee (go figure).
Like in most aspects of life, its a gamble. some times it pays off, other times it don't. You explore your options, get 2nd opinions, then make your choice. The one thing that I would stress is that, whether its your first choice or your last resort, consider surgery as a 'permanent' thing. If they cut it out, chances are they ain't gonna put it back, OK?
Other than that, my surgeries were cake walks. Easy. I never had an issue or complaint.