Non-Hodgkin's Lymphomas cancers reported to the FDA with TNF-α Inhibitors

Crohn's Disease Forum

Help Support Crohn's Disease Forum:

kiny

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 28, 2011
Messages
3,463
http://www.nature.com/ajg/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/ajg2012334a.html

October 2012

T-Cell Non-Hodgkin's Lymphomas Reported to the FDA AERS With Tumor Necrosis Factor-Alpha (TNF-α) Inhibitors: Results of the REFURBISH Study

OBJECTIVES:

The risk of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL) with tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α) inhibitors is unclear, whether related to concomitant thiopurines usage or due to the underlying inflammatory disease. We sought to review all cases of T-cell NHL reported to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in patients receiving TNF-α inhibitors for all approved indications and examine the risk of T-cell NHL with TNF-α inhibitors in comparison with the use of thiopurines in inflammatory bowel disease (IBD).

METHODS:

The FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (AERS) was queried for all lymphomas following treatment with the following TNF-α inhibitors: infliximab, adalimumab, certolizumab, etanercept, and their trade names. Full reports for T-cell NHL cases were identified using the Freedom of Information Act. In addition, T-cell NHL reported in patients IBD with the use of the thiopurines-azathioprine, 6-mercaptopurine, and their trade names were also collected. A search of MEDLINE was performed for additional T-cell NHL with TNF-α inhibitors or thiopurines, not reported to the FDA but available in published literature. The histological subtypes of T-cell NHL reported with TNF-α inhibitors were compared with reported subtypes in Surveillance Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) -17 registry. Reported risk of T-cell NHL in IBD with TNF-α inhibitors, thiopurines, or concomitant use was calculated using Fisher's exact test using 5-aminosalicylates as control drugs.

RESULTS:

A total of 3,130,267 reports were downloaded from the FDA AERS (2003–2010). Ninety-one cases of T-cell NHL with TNF-α inhibitors were identified in the FDA AERS and nine additional cases were identified on MEDLINE search. A total of 38 patients had rheumatoid arthritis, 36 cases had Crohn's disease, 11 had psoriasis, 9 had ulcerative colitis, and 6 had ankylosing spondylitis. Sixty-eight of the cases (68%) involved exposure to both a TNF-α inhibitor and an immunomodulator (azathioprine, 6-mercaptopurine, methotrexate, leflunomide, or cyclosporine). Hepatosplenic T-cell lymphoma (HSTCL) was the most common reported subtype, whereas mycosis fungoides/Sezary syndrome and HSTCL were identified as more common with TNF-α-inhibitor exposure compared with SEER-17 registry. Nineteen cases of T-cell NHL with thiopurines were identified in the FDA AERS and one additional case on MEDLINE. Reported risk of T-cell NHL was higher with TNF-α inhibitor use in combination with thiopurines (95% confidence interval (CI) 4.98–354.09; P<0.0001) and thiopurines alone (95% CI 8.32–945.38; P<0.0001) but not with TNF-α inhibitor use alone (95% CI 0.13–10.61; P=1.00).

CONCLUSIONS:

Risk of T-cell NHL is increased with TNF-α inhibitor use in combination with thiopurines but not with TNF-α inhibitors alone.
 
What I don't really agree with is the second part of the conclusion, those cases that had cancers, they were highest for people on combo therapy, and lower, or within normal bounds of single therapy of TNF blockers.

But the immunomodulator alone is not enough to create the rates of immunomodulator and TNF blocker together, so the TNF blocker is contributing to the increased risk, if you just read the conclusion you could argue that the TNF blocker isn't increasing the risk, it's the immunomodulator alone, but that's not true, because it's the combo that is causing the highest rates. So the TNF blocker is most definitely contributing to the risk.
 
Thanks Kiny
That article really helps.

the same group had done previous work in 2011 see here

Results: Twenty-five cases of HSTCL were identified. Twenty-two (88%) patients had inflammatory bowel disease and three had rheumatoid arthritis. Four cases (16%) were in women and four patients were above 65 years of age. Twenty-four cases (96%) also received an immunomodulator (azathioprine, 6-mercaptopurine, or methotrexate). Two patients received adalimumab alone.

From:
http://mobile.journals.lww.com/euro...ewer.aspx?year=2011&issue=12000&article=00009



Conclusion: HSTCL is no longer restricted to the previously identified risk group of young male patients, but can also occur in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, females and older adults receiving TNF-α inhibitors and immunomodulators. Improved disease outcomes using combination therapy should be tempered by the risk of developing HSTCL.

but not as extensive as this new article.
 
I want to point out that the increased number of cases reported s potentially misleading in terms of this forum.

The total number of Crohn's cases reported in this study was 36 and the total number of UC cases was 9. Compared to the previous report by the FDA in 4/2011 this has only increased by 6 Crohn's cases.

So these are the total number of identified cases covering the period 2003 to 2010. Out of 3,130,267 cases pulled for review by this research study. Since they don't split that number up by diagnosis I suppose you could say that my own comparison is misleading. If we take the results and assume that the IBD patients represented 45% of the total patients then we are talking 45 patients out of 1,408,620.

I am not a statistical expert but I find myself questioning the statistical validity of a study that has so very few cases from which to draw conclusions given that the patients have five different conditions. And we know that patients with IBD do not necessarily react to these meds the same way as patients with RA, the next largest group of identified patients. Plus some of the cancers were NHL's not HSTCL.

The bottom line is that I think more information is needed and even with more information I do not think the risks are going to end up outweighing the benefits for the vast majority of patients and their families - given that these are patients with severe disease.

When it comes down to a real life assessment of this information, my conclusions are that:

Is there an increased risk? Yes, I think that is clear.

How big is that risk? Very, very small.

Do we know how much/if there is a increased risk from using a combo? No, although common sense would suggest that there is - again a tiny risk

Do we know these drugs are saving peoples lives? yes

Do we know that using AZA or MTX reduces the rate that the body produces antibodies to biologics allowing biologics to be used for longer periods of time? Yes, we know that

Do we know that uncontrolled Crohn's significantly increases a person's risk of bowel cancer? Yes by roughly 5 times

Is the risk of bowel cancer from uncontrolled inflammation greater than the risk of these cancers? Almost certainly by several orders of magnitude.

There are risks. There are benefits. Each person has to figure out how to strike a balance they can live with. And you can always change your mind.

Peace.
 
Do we know if there is a increased risk from using a combo? No

Yes we do, that's what the study showed and why I linked it in the first place, read the topic you're replying to.

"Risk of T-cell NHL is increased with TNF-α inhibitor use in combination with thiopurines"


They have known this for a while, you can go look into journals, individual doctors were the first to pull on the alarm bell because they kept seeing it happen with combo therapy. This is not the first study that has pointed this out. Many clinics have stopped combo therapy. Trying to minimalise this in any way is irresponsible.

This is also not about weighing chances, this isn't roulette in a casino, people who are immune compromised and get NHL are a goner, go look at the individual cases, they survive anywhere from a few days to a few weeks, this is not a mild cancer, this is a killer cancer that kills those people.

They should do everything in their power to minimize that risk, crohn is not a disease that tends to kill people if they are cared for, it wasn't when Dalziel wrote about the cases being cared for in 1913, it shouldn't be in 2012, medication should be continuously evaluated and everyone who takes combo therapy should be aware of the risks.

There was a personal account from a doctor you can find on pubmed, it was titled "is this worth it", he talks about a patient he lost on combo therapy, no one should be dying from medication for crohn.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top